Every once in a while I have to be pushed towards my luck. My best friend has been telling me about ‘North and South’ for quite a while and every single time I thought of it as another (lesser) version of ‘Pride and Prejudice’. Both stories are set in 19th century England, both tell of misunderstandings and the trouble of finding true love. And because of how highly I regard ‘Pride and Prejudice’ (the 1995 version of course) I didn’t even want to give ‘North and South’ a chance.
But then I saw ‘The Hobbit’ and was pretty impressed by its lead dwarf Thorin Oakenshield played by Richard Armitage. And since I was already feeling a little bit homesick to England I figured I might as well go ahead and finally bought that BBC Miniseries he was in and that I heard so much about – just had to make sure not to buy the US-show with the same name that has Patrick Swayze and El Wood’s dad fighting each other in the US civil war.
BBC ‘North & South’ is based on the book written by Elizabeth Gaskell. It takes place around 1850 and at this time the industrial revolution was in full swing in the north while the south of England was still very much centred around agriculture. After living 10 years in London with her cousin, Margret Hale (Daniela Denby-Ashe) returns happily to the southern town of Helstone where her father is the local pastor. Because he disagreed with the church he tells his family that he decided to leave the church and become a tutor. He has a friend in the north that supports him in the move so the whole family is leaving the quiet south in order to move to the industrial north – to the fictional town of Milton. Upon arrival Margret meets the harsh reality of industrialization and how it changes the way of living – she also meets John Thornton…queue handsome Richard Armitage. John becomes a pupil of Margret’s father while Margret through her friendship with the factory workers becomes more involved in the social movement that is led by Nicholas Higgins (Downton Abbey Alum Brendan Coyle). Through the course of the story, Margret and John become more and more acquainted with each other but before the happy ending, a lot of things happen.
With the two leads disliking each other at first, a proposal that is too early and the knowledge that the two leads will end up with each other in the end one can easily start to compare it to Pride & Prejudice. But this is pretty much where the comparison ends. Jane Austen was mainly occupied with detailing the live on the country and describing the balls the people went to. Elizabeth Gaskell goes further and allows the reader / viewer to really get to know what life back then meant for workers in the mills but also what this change meant to society. John Thornton came from a poor background working his way up to being a mill owner – the only way people earned money in Jane Austen novels was through the death of a relative. Now before anybody thinks I am suddenly dissing the Great Austen…no way! ‘Pride & Prejudice’ is still one of the greatest love stories ever written but I have to say in comparison ‘North and South’ is just a tad more challenging and even educating. While John Thornton shows Margret what it means to have responsibility for workers and being the maker of his own destiny. Margret on the other hand becomes friendly with the workers and shows John that a social note is sometimes helpful to get ahead. In the end both people grow and learn from each others strengths and weaknesses.
And when it comes to brooding – Heathcliff got nothing on Richard Armitage. He tries really hard to be all mean and uninterested but once he says very quietly ‘Look back at me’ I can’t imagine any women not sitting there, sighing in desperation that it’s not them he asks to turn around. Armitage is able to let his emotions speak through his eyes without saying a thing. I am so happy he finally gets some much-needed international recognition through ‘The Hobbit’. Daniela Denby-Ashe is a revelation as Margret – sensitive and strong though I pity her for those corsets she had to wear throughout the movie. Together, they make a couple that can rival Lizzy and Mr. Darcy and though I never thought I would say this – but I believe I like ‘North and South’ as much as I love ‘Pride & Prejudice’…maybe even more? I think I will have to watch it all just once again đ